What Hardness Should I Set My Water Softener To? Your Measured Number, and Why It Matters
Set it to the measured hardness of your water, in grains per gallon — not the factory default and not a neighbor's setting. Both control-valve manuals we read ask for the feed-water hardness in grains, and the control uses it to work out how many gallons the resin can soften before it regenerates [1][2]. Get the number from your utility's water quality report or a test at your tap; if it is given in ppm or mg/L, divide by about 17 [5]. Set it too high and the softener regenerates more often than it needs to, using extra salt and water; set it too low and hard water comes through before each regeneration.

What hardness should I set my water softener to?
The hardness of the water coming into the softener, in grains per gallon. Pentair's service manual for the Fleck 5600SXT control calls the setting feedwater hardness (display code H), asks for it in grains per unit volume for a softener, and allows 1 to 199 [1]. Clack's manual for the WS1CS control asks for grains of hardness as calcium carbonate per gallon, from 1 to 150 in one-grain steps [2]. These are two makers' instructions, not necessarily the brand on your wall, but the idea is the same on any metered softener.
Do not leave the default. The Clack control ships set to 20 grains [2], which is a starting value, not your water. The setting is entered on the control head with the display — on the two tanks in the photo at the top of this page, in Bradenton, that is the head on top of each tank.
The number matters because the control does a division with it. It takes the capacity of the resin bed in grains, divides by the hardness, and gets the gallons it can soften before it has to regenerate [1]; Clack's control does the same when its volume capacity is set to AUTO, calculating it from the grains capacity and the water hardness [2]. Get the hardness wrong and every regeneration comes at the wrong time. How often that adds up to, and the reserve held back for overnight regeneration, are covered in how often a softener should regenerate.
Where do I find my water hardness number?
From your water utility first, then from a test at your tap. The U.S. Geological Survey points people to their local water utility or health agency for local hardness information [4]. Your utility is the one named on your water bill, and its yearly water quality report usually lists hardness; the City of Tampa says it will send its latest report on request [5].
Some reports give you the softener number directly. Pinellas County Utilities' report for 2025 lists a line headed water softener setting for hardness: equivalent to 11.1–14.3 grains per gallon [6]. Most give hardness in ppm or mg/L instead; to convert, divide by about 17 — the City of Tampa uses 1 grain per gallon = 17.2 ppm [5].
We do not repeat every utility's figure here: our page on how hard Tampa Bay water is, utility by utility lists them with their sources. A published range tells you roughly where you are; a test at your own tap tells you where you are now.
Can I check my water hardness with test strips?
Yes, for a working number. University of Nebraska–Lincoln Extension notes that test kits and dip strips are available for hardness testing outside a laboratory, and that greater reliability and accuracy can be expected from laboratory testing [3]. It adds that testing laboratories, some health departments and some equipment dealers can test for hardness [3].
Test the water going into the softener — an outside tap or a sample taken with the softener in bypass — because that is the number the control needs. Water from a softened tap tells you something else: whether the softener is doing its job. That is our reading of the manuals, which ask for the feed-water hardness [1][2].
If a strip reads in mg/L or ppm, convert it to grains as above before you enter it.
What happens if my softener's hardness is set too high?
It regenerates more often than it needs to, and each extra regeneration costs salt and water. A higher hardness setting makes the division come out smaller, so the control counts down fewer gallons before it calls for a regeneration [1] — in the drawing above, 25 instead of 15 cuts 2,000 gallons to 1,200, and the resin is regenerated with two-fifths of its capacity still unused.
The salt used per regeneration is its own setting — Clack's control asks for pounds of salt per regeneration [2], and the Fleck job sheet has a line for the salt setting per regeneration [1] — so more regenerations means more salt. Nebraska Extension puts the water used by one regeneration at about 50 gallons, and notes the extra load each one puts on a septic system [3].
Setting the number high “to be safe” therefore has a running cost. If a softener seems to use more salt than expected, Nebraska Extension advises having a service provider check the settings [3], and the Fleck troubleshooting table lists an improper salt setting as a cause of too much salt use [1].
What happens if my softener's hardness is set too low?
Hard water gets through before each regeneration. A lower setting makes the control expect more gallons than the resin can actually soften [1], so the resin is spent while the meter still shows gallons left, and hard water flows until the next regeneration. In the drawing above, a setting of 10 on 15-grain water lets about a third of the gallons between regenerations come through hard.
The Fleck manual uses the phrase hard water break-through for this kind of failure when it explains the reserve [1], and Nebraska Extension notes that a softener must be kept regenerated to avoid hard water flowing into pipes and appliances [3].
The usual sign is spotting and scale returning in the days before a regeneration, then soft water again just after it. A low setting is not the only cause: the Fleck troubleshooting table lists hard water from an open bypass valve, no salt in the brine tank, a plugged injector screen and too little water flowing into the brine tank [1]. If the salt level has not moved in weeks, check for a salt bridge before changing any setting.

Should I set the hardness higher if my water has iron?
Only as your softener's maker directs, and only for small amounts of dissolved iron. Clack's WS1CS manual says the grains-per-gallon setting can be increased if soluble iron needs to be reduced, but gives no figure for how much [2]. The Fleck 5600SXT manual gives no iron adjustment to the hardness setting; it says that if the piping is clogged with iron, a separate iron filter unit should be installed ahead of the softener [1].
Retail websites give rules of thumb for adding grains per part per million of iron, and they do not agree with each other; neither manual we read gives one. Ask the maker of your valve or resin for its figure rather than borrowing one.
There is a ceiling, too. Nebraska Extension says a softener may remove as much as 5–10 ppm of iron and manganese, that you should check the manufacturer's rating, that higher amounts may need pretreatment such as a greensand filter, and that iron above 5 ppm can reduce a softener's effectiveness [3]. Iron in well water is usually a filter question first — see how to remove iron from well water.
Do I need to reset my softener when my water changes?
Yes — the setting should follow the water. The City of Oldsmar, whose water is now much softer than the county water it used to buy, tells customers they may need to adjust their water softener to the current hardness levels [7]. The City of Tampa says its own water's hardness fluctuates through the year, lower in the wet season and higher in the dry season [5].
Re-test and re-enter the number when you move into a house with an existing softener, when you switch between a well and city water, when your utility announces a change in supply or treatment, or when soft water starts turning hard before regenerations. Both controls keep this setting easy to reach: on the Fleck 5600SXT the hardness is in User Programming, opened by holding the Up and Down buttons for five seconds in service [1]; on the Clack WS1CS it is the first of the Installer Display Settings, opened by holding NEXT and ▲ together for three seconds, and it stays adjustable even when the other settings are locked [2].
Setting a softener in Clearwater and across Tampa Bay
Start with the utility on your bill. In Pinellas County, the county utility prints a softener setting in its water quality report — 11.1 to 14.3 grains per gallon for 2025 [6]. The City of Tampa publishes a hardness range that moves with the seasons [5], and cities with their own treatment can be much softer: Oldsmar's water is now 1.6–3.7 grains per gallon by its own figures [7]. Our hard-water-by-utility page has the rest.
When a utility gives a range rather than one number, setting toward the top of it trades a little salt for fewer hard-water days; setting toward the bottom does the opposite. That is our reading of the calculation [1], not a rule from a manual — a test at your own tap settles it.
Whoever sets up or resets the softener should enter the measured hardness of the water going into it rather than leave the factory default in place.
We can test the water going in, read the settings on the control and set the hardness to match. Kate, our AI voice assistant, answers the phone 24/7 and takes the request; site work is Monday to Friday, 8am to 6pm.
Call 727-470-7126FAQ
What number do I put in my water softener for hardness?
The measured hardness of the water going into the softener, in grains per gallon. The Fleck 5600SXT and Clack WS1CS manuals both ask for the feed-water hardness in grains [1][2].
Should I set my water softener higher than my water hardness?
Not by habit. A higher setting makes the control regenerate sooner than needed, and every regeneration uses salt and about 50 gallons of water [1][3]. The exception is small amounts of dissolved iron, where Clack says the setting can be increased; follow your softener maker's figure [2].
How do I convert ppm to grains per gallon for my softener?
Divide by about 17. The City of Tampa uses 1 grain per gallon = 17.2 ppm, so 170 ppm is about 10 grains [5]. For water, ppm and mg/L are the same.
What is the water hardness in Clearwater and Tampa?
It depends on your utility, not the city on your address. Pinellas County Utilities' 2025 report gives a softener setting of 11.1–14.3 grains per gallon [6], and the City of Tampa's hardness changes with the season [5]. Our hard-water-by-utility page lists each utility's figure.
What happens if the hardness setting on my softener is too low?
The control expects more gallons than the resin can soften, so hard water comes through before each regeneration [1][3]. Check the bypass valve and the salt too: the Fleck troubleshooting table lists both as causes of hard water [1].
Why is my softener using so much salt?
A hardness set higher than your water is one reason: it makes the softener regenerate more often [1]. The Fleck manual also lists an improper salt setting [1], and Nebraska Extension advises having the settings checked when salt use is higher than expected [3].
Are water hardness test strips accurate enough to set a softener?
They give a working number. Nebraska Extension says test kits and dip strips are available for home testing and that laboratory testing is more reliable and accurate [3]. Test the water going into the softener, not a softened tap.
Do I need to change my softener setting if my city's water changes?
Yes. Oldsmar, whose water is now much softer than the county water it used to buy, tells customers they may need to adjust their softeners to the current hardness [7]. Re-test and re-enter the number whenever the supply changes.
Sources
We review and cite. We do not reproduce a paper or a manual — follow the links for the originals.
- [1]Fleck 5600SXT Downflow Service Manual — Pentair · 2018Manufacturer's manual · 42684 Rev L MY18. Feedwater Hardness (display code H): enter the feedwater hardness in grains per unit volume for softener systems, range 1–199; master chart: 'Hardness of Inlet Water (Grains)'; also in User Programming (hold Up and Down five seconds in service); system capacity = unit capacity ÷ feed water hardness − reserve; reserve set to prevent 'hard water break-through' in twin-tank systems; job specification sheet lines for water hardness (ppm or gpg) and salt setting per regeneration; existing plumbing: if piping is clogged with iron, install a separate iron filter ahead of the softener; no iron adjustment to the hardness setting found; troubleshooting: hard water — bypass open, no salt, injector screen plugged, insufficient water into brine tank; too much salt — improper salt setting. One maker's instructions, not necessarily the brand we install. Read 2026-11-09.
- [2]Water Specialist WS1CS & WS1.25CS Operation and Instruction Manual (Form No. V3115CS) — Clack Corporation · 2023Manufacturer's manual · Form V3115CS, 10/9/2023. Installer Display Settings (press NEXT and ▲ together 3 seconds), Step 2I Hardness: grains of hardness as calcium carbonate per gallon, default 20, range 1–150 in one-grain increments; note: 'The grains per gallon can be increased if soluble iron needs to be reduced' (no figure given); Step 6S grains capacity; Step 7S pounds of salt per regeneration; Step 8S volume capacity AUTO calculated from grains capacity and water hardness; lockout leaves hardness, day override, regeneration time and time of day adjustable. One maker's instructions, not necessarily the brand we install. Read 2026-11-09.
- [3]Drinking Water Treatment: Water Softening (Ion Exchange), G1491 — Sharon O. Skipton, Bruce I. Dvorak · University of Nebraska–Lincoln Extension · revised September 2014University extension · hardness often expressed in grains per gallon; test kits and dip strips available for testing outside a laboratory, greater reliability and accuracy with laboratory testing; labs, some health departments and some equipment dealers test hardness; softeners may remove as much as 5–10 ppm iron and manganese — check the manufacturer's rating; higher concentrations may need pretreatment such as greensand; iron above 5 ppm can reduce effectiveness; softener must be kept regenerated to avoid hard water flowing into pipes and appliances; about 50 gallons per regeneration, extra septic load; if a unit uses more salt than expected, have a service provider check the settings. Read 2026-11-09.
- [4]Hardness of Water — Water Science School · U.S. Geological Survey · 2026Government or standards body · hardness is the amount of dissolved calcium and magnesium; bands in mg/L as calcium carbonate; for local information contact the local health agency or water utility; national map not designed for individual homes; no grains conversion on the page; dated 2026-08-24. Read 2026-11-09.
- [5]Frequently Asked Questions — City of Tampa Water Department · 2026Government or standards body · hardness about 140–300 ppm (8–17 grains per gallon), fluctuating through the year, lower in the wet season and higher in the dry season; one grain per gallon equals 17.2 ppm; the city will send its latest water quality report on request. Read 2026-11-09.
- [6]2025 Consumer Confidence Report on Drinking Water Quality — Pinellas County Utilities · 2026Government or standards body · page 11: total hardness 217 ppm, range 189–244; 'Water softener setting for hardness: Equivalent to 11.1 - 14.3 grains per gallon'. Read 2026-11-09.
- [7]Water FAQ — City of OldsmarGovernment or standards body · city water much softer than the water previously purchased from Pinellas County Utilities; 28–64 mg/L or ppm, equivalent to 1.6–3.7 grains per gallon; a softener is a personal preference; 'You may need to adjust your water softener to the current hardness levels.' Read 2026-11-09.
Questions About Your Own System?
Send a photo of what you have. We answer with what it is and what it needs.
See our Water Treatment & Softeners service →
Licensed CFC1432506 · Insured · Clearwater, FL + 50 miles
